Spacez insight · March 2026 · 6 min read
Should You Fitout, Move, or Stay? A Melbourne Business Decision Guide
Commercial fitout services in Melbourne. Should You Fitout, Move, or Stay? A Melbourne Business Decision Guide. Get a free quote from Spacez.
Your lease is coming up for renewal. Or your current space isn't working. Or you've grown out of your layout. Whatever the trigger, you're facing a decision that most Melbourne businesses handle emotionally rather than analytically — and nearly always regret either rushing into or putting off too long.
The three options: fitout your current space, move to a new tenancy (and fitout that), or do nothing and renew the lease as-is. Here's how to make the decision with clear thinking.
First: What's Actually Driving the Question?
Before comparing costs, get clear on what's actually wrong (or right) about your current situation. The drivers are usually one of:
- Space size: You've grown and you don't have enough desks, meeting rooms, or general space
- Fitout quality: The space is dated, dysfunctional, or no longer reflects your brand
- Location: The suburb or address no longer serves your clients, staff, or business strategy
- Cost: Your current rent is above or below market, and renewal gives you a renegotiation moment
- Lease obligation: Your lease is expiring and you need to decide — renew, refurbish, or leave
Only one of these problems requires moving: location. All others can potentially be solved by staying and fitout out. Be honest about which problem you actually have before defaulting to "we should find somewhere new."
Option 1: Fitout Your Current Space
Best when: Your location works, your space size is right (or close to right), and the main issue is fitout quality or layout.
Advantages
- No disruption to operations: A fitout can be staged to minimise business disruption. A relocation means a complete move — systems cut-over, address changes, client notifications, staff upheaval.
- No make-good cost on departure: Leaving your current tenancy triggers make-good obligations. Staying and fitting out avoids this cost entirely.
- Landlord contribution: A lease renewal with a fitout is a strong negotiating position for a Tenant Improvement Allowance. Melbourne landlords will often contribute $150–$400/sqm toward a fitout if you commit to a longer term. This significantly reduces your net fitout cost.
- Known building: You know the building's quirks, the building manager, the HVAC behaviour, the loading dock access. Moving to a new building brings unknowns.
Disadvantages
- Some buildings have physical constraints — low ceilings, poor natural light, outdated services — that no fitout can fully overcome
- If the location is wrong, a great fitout won't fix it
- Construction in an occupied tenancy requires staging and creates disruption even with the best project management
The Numbers
A 300sqm mid-spec Melbourne office fitout costs $300,000–$550,000 gross. With a $200/sqm TIA on a 5-year renewal, the landlord contributes $60,000 — net cost $240,000–$490,000. Amortised over 5 years: $48,000–$98,000 per year.
Option 2: Move to a New Tenancy
Best when: Your location no longer serves your business, your space size is fundamentally wrong, or the building has irremediable physical problems.
Advantages
- Fresh start: A new tenancy gives you a blank canvas — the right size, the right layout, in the right location
- Better base build: Newer buildings often have better base build quality — higher ceilings, better natural light, more efficient HVAC — that makes fitout investment go further
- Competitive TIA: In Melbourne's current commercial property market, competing landlords will offer TIAs to attract quality tenants — sometimes more generously than a sitting tenant can negotiate from an existing landlord
- Signal to staff and clients: A new office in a new location is a visible statement of growth and ambition that a refurbishment of the existing space doesn't achieve as powerfully
Disadvantages
- Make-good cost on departure: Most Melbourne commercial leases require you to remove your fitout and restore the tenancy on exit. For a 300sqm fitout, make-good typically costs $40,000–$120,000.
- Moving costs: IT migration, removalist, address changes, client communication, staff disruption — typically $15,000–$60,000 for a 20–50 person team
- Two fitouts: You're fitting out a new tenancy in addition to make-good on the old one — the total cost is higher than staying and refurbishing
- Operational disruption: A move is a significant business interruption — systems go down, files get lost, productivity drops for weeks around the move
The Numbers
Moving costs for a 30-person Melbourne business: make-good ($60,000) + moving costs ($30,000) + new fitout ($400,000 gross, less $80,000 TIA = $320,000 net) = total $410,000. Higher than staying put, plus the disruption premium.
Option 3: Renew and Do Nothing
Best when: Your current fitout is genuinely still functional and presentable, and your primary concern is cost minimisation.
Advantages
- No capital expenditure on fitout or move
- No disruption
- Preserves capital for the core business
Disadvantages
- The hidden cost of a bad office is real: Staff attrition, talent rejection, productivity drag, and client impression cost are ongoing. A dated office that doesn't serve your team costs money — it just doesn't appear on a capital expenditure line.
- Lost negotiating leverage: The lease renewal moment is the strongest leverage you have with your landlord. Using it to simply renew at market rent without negotiating a TIA or fitout contribution is leaving value on the table.
- Deferred decision: If your fitout is genuinely end-of-life, deferring only makes it worse — and more expensive when you eventually have to act.
The Decision Framework
Work through these questions in order:
- Is your location fundamentally right for the next 5 years? If no → move. If yes → continue.
- Is your space the right size for your projected headcount? If significantly too small or too large and can't be sub-let → consider moving. If roughly right → continue.
- Does your building have irremediable physical problems (structural ceiling height under 2.7m, no natural light, chronic HVAC problems)? If yes → move. If no → continue.
- Is your fitout fundamentally broken (acoustics, layout, brand presentation)? If yes → fitout. If manageable → consider doing nothing for now.
- What is your landlord offering for renewal? A generous TIA changes the economics of staying significantly. Get a renewal proposal before you search for new space.
Making the Most of a Lease Renewal Negotiation
Regardless of which option you choose, the lease renewal moment is your highest-leverage negotiating point. Use it:
- Get competing proposals: Even if you intend to stay, inspect 2–3 comparable alternatives and get heads of agreement proposals from those landlords. This gives you genuine leverage at your existing building.
- Negotiate TIA before you commit to staying: Melbourne market TIAs for renewed tenants in 2026 range from $100–$400/sqm depending on building class, lease term, and market conditions. Don't accept the landlord's first offer.
- Negotiate a rent-free fitout period: 4–8 weeks rent-free while you're under construction is a further cost reduction worth $15,000–$50,000 for a typical Melbourne tenancy.
- Consider a make-good negotiation: If your fitout is dated and the landlord wants to re-lease it to a new tenant, they may accept cash-in-lieu of make-good (contribute a lower cash amount instead of demolishing your fitout). This reduces your departure cost if you eventually do move.
When to Start This Process
Start 12 months before your lease expiry. This gives you:
- Time to inspect alternatives and develop genuine negotiating leverage
- Time to get a fitout design and cost estimate before committing to stay
- Time to complete a fitout within the lease term if you choose to renew
- Time to find a new tenancy and fitout it before your current lease ends if you choose to move
Businesses that start this process 6 months out are almost always under time pressure. At 12 months, you have all the options. At 6 months, you're making reactive decisions.
Get a Quote: Contact Spacez for a free initial consultation — including a preliminary assessment of whether a fitout of your current tenancy or a new tenancy fitout makes more financial sense for your business.
Spacez — Melbourne Commercial Fitout Specialists. Smart decisions, well built.